Chronic otitis media early in childhood is often voiced as a concern for speech-language delay, though the research is inconclusive.
Animals studies that induce chronic conductive pathologies can result in significant changes in central auditory pathways, including peripheral afferent and efferent neural innervation. However, in general, these animal studies create significant pathologies over extended periods of time without resolve and consistent sound stimulation.
For most children, conductive pathologies are mild to moderate in nature and only transient and likely have minimal implications for speech and language. Nonetheless, more chronic and severe conductive pathologies may create neural and synaptopathic deficits similar to animal models.
Okada et al. (2019) performed a retrospective review of 196 patients with chronic and acute conductive pathologies in one ear and normal hearing sensitivity in the contralateral ear. Bone conduction thresholds were normal in both ears. Participants were grouped by condition type, acute vs. chronic nature, and severity of conductive hearing loss ( air conduction thresholds >< 40 dBHL).
W-22, 50-word lists were presented with a contralateral speech-shaped noise. The presentation level was a minimal at 70 dBHL, but otherwise based on maximal audibility based on the Articulation Index. The results demonstrated significantly lower word recognition scores for ears with chronic conductive pathology higher than 40dBHL, but not for acute or more mild to moderate variants of conductive loss.
The authors suggest this may be reflective of synapatopathy due to chronic deprivation and suggest amplification and other means of stimulation to intervene. There are some limitations.
First, it is unclear if audibility was achieved for all participants, no increase in the intensity of speech stimuli was completed to see if scores improved.
Second, the amount of mean difference in word recognition scores for the most significant difference (chronic congenital pathology > 40 dBHL), was approximately 10 percent (98 percent in the normal ear and 88 percent in the ear with pathology). Although this is statistically significant, may have limited clinical significance.
Finally, the authors could have attempted speech testing through a bone-conduction transducer to see if there was any difference when testing around the conductive pathology.
Reference
Okada et al. (2019) Chronic conductive hearing loss is associated with speech intelligibility deficits in patients with normal bone conduction thresholds. Ear & Hearing, pre pub.
Related Posts
Another Useless Body Part…
If you have a dog or cat, you’ve probably seen their ears moving toward an interesting or startling sound. For professional equestrians, watching the ears of their horse allows them to gauge their shifting attention. Humans still have these same muscles, and even more interesting is their relationship to our brain and how we pay attention. …
Memorizing Movements: How Tai Chi Can Improve Balance and Cognition
Tai Chi is not just for increasing balance; it may also help improve cognitive performance. In a recent randomized controlled trial, study participants who practiced a form of Tai Chi twice a week for six months improved their scores on the Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA) when compared to a control group (Fuzhong et al, 2023)….
Skyquakes—Did You Hear It?
The majority of people are familiar with earthquakes, but there is another phenomenon that is not nearly as predictable, and louder—skyquakes. Skyquakes are enigmatic sounds, typically described as a very loud boom or trumpet-sounding noise that has no apparent cause and seems to come from the sky. Their sound is like distant, but very loud, thunder with…